← Back to Events
Meissner effect confirmed near room temperature?
This market will resolve to "Yes" if the Meissner effect claimed in the paper https://arxiv.org/abs/2401.00999 is replicated by December 31, 2024 ET. Otherwise this market will resolve to "No." The resolution source for this market will be a consensus of credible sources and experts verifying the legitimacy of the replication(s). This market may only resolve once a definitive consensus is reached.
Event Details
Total Volume: $375.6K
24h Volume: $1.0K
Total Liquidity: $27.6K
Markets: 1
Event Ends: 12/31/2024
Event Analysis
Summary
The prediction market centers on whether the Meissner effect - a key indicator of superconductivity - will be confirmed near room temperature by credible sources before December 31, 2024. This follows claims made in early 2024 by researchers about observing the effect in copper-substituted lead apatite materials.
The scientific community has approached these claims with significant skepticism, particularly given recent controversies surrounding room-temperature superconductivity claims like LK-99. While some promising research has emerged, including new quantum sensing techniques for studying superconductivity, the bar for definitive confirmation remains very high. With just over a month remaining until the market resolution date, time is running short for achieving the required scientific consensus.
Analysis
Scientific Background
- The Meissner effect is the expulsion of magnetic fields from a superconductor during its transition to the superconducting state
- Room temperature superconductivity has been a holy grail of materials science, with potential revolutionary applications
- Previous claims of room temperature superconductivity have failed to withstand scientific scrutiny
Recent Developments
- January 2024: Wang et al. published claims of possible Meissner effect in copper-substituted lead apatite
- March 2024: Follow-up paper on sulfur-copper codoped lead apatite showing diamagnetic properties
- February 2024: Important methodological advances in imaging Meissner effect using quantum sensors
- Late 2023: Debunking of LK-99 room temperature superconductivity claims
Key Factors Influencing Outcome
- Time Pressure
- Only ~1 month remains until market resolution
- Scientific consensus typically requires multiple independent replications
- Peer review process can take many months
- Technical Challenges
- Replication requires precise material synthesis
- Measurements must be carefully controlled
- Multiple independent confirmations needed
- Historical Context
- No room temperature superconductor claims have been validated to date
- Scientific community maintains high skepticism after recent failed claims
- Burden of proof is extremely high
Trading Considerations
- Short time remaining makes "No" resolution highly likely
- Even if claims are valid, consensus unlikely by deadline
- Risk/reward favors "No" positions at current prices
- Limited upside potential in "Yes" positions given timeline
Prediction
Given the December 31, 2024 deadline and requirement for scientific consensus, I predict with high confidence (9/10) that this market will resolve to "No". While the underlying research shows promise, the timeline is too short for achieving the required level of validation and replication. I estimate a 99% probability of "No" and 1% probability of "Yes".
Meissner effect confirmed near room temperature?
Yes:1.0%
No:99.0%
Confidence: 9/10
Reasoning Score: 8/10