← Back to Events
OpenAI settlement with NYT by end of 2024?
This market will resolve to “Yes” if it is announced that OpenAI has reached a settlement with the New York Times over copyright infringement issues by December 31, 2024, 11:59 PM ET. Otherwise this market will resolve to “No.” The resolution source will be a consensus of credible reporting.
Event Details
Total Volume: $20.2K
24h Volume: $13
Total Liquidity: $1.5K
Markets: 1
Event Ends: 12/31/2024
Event Analysis
Summary
The legal battle between The New York Times and OpenAI represents a landmark case in the emerging field of AI copyright law. Filed in December 2023, the lawsuit alleges that OpenAI and Microsoft unlawfully used NYT's copyrighted content to train their AI models, with the Times seeking billions in damages and requesting the destruction of models trained on their content.
Recent developments, including OpenAI's motion to dismiss parts of the lawsuit and their strong defense claiming fair use, suggest that both parties are preparing for a lengthy legal battle rather than an imminent settlement. The complexity of the legal issues at stake, combined with OpenAI's firm stance on fair use and the NYT's determination to protect its intellectual property, indicates that reaching a settlement before the end of 2024 faces significant challenges.
Analysis
Legal Background
- NYT filed lawsuit in December 2023 alleging copyright infringement
- Seeking billions in damages and destruction of AI models trained on their content
- Claims involve both training data usage and model outputs
- OpenAI defending based on fair use doctrine
Current Status
- OpenAI has filed motion to dismiss parts of the lawsuit
- Negotiations attempted prior to lawsuit filing were unsuccessful
- OpenAI claims NYT manipulated prompts to generate evidence
- No indication of active settlement discussions
Key Factors Influencing Settlement Likelihood
Factors Decreasing Settlement Probability:
- OpenAI's strong legal defense and fair use claims
- Recent motion to dismiss indicating commitment to litigation
- Complex legal questions requiring judicial interpretation
- Limited time remaining in 2024 for resolution
Factors Increasing Settlement Probability:
- Prior history of attempted negotiations
- Precedent of other media companies reaching AI licensing deals
- Potential reputational damage to both parties
- High costs of prolonged litigation
Recent Developments
- February 2024: OpenAI filed detailed legal defense
- Claims of NYT deliberately manipulating prompts
- Public statements indicating hardened positions
- Industry watching case as potential precedent
Market Implications
- Current market pricing (85.5% No) appears justified
- Limited catalysts for settlement in near term
- Legal proceedings likely to extend beyond 2024
- High stakes for both parties reduce compromise incentives
Prediction
Based on the available evidence, I agree with the market's assessment that a settlement is unlikely before the end of 2024. I estimate a 15% probability of settlement, with 85% probability of no settlement by year-end. The hardened legal positions, complex nature of the copyright issues, and limited remaining time in 2024 all suggest resolution is unlikely this year. Confidence level is 8/10 given the clear legal positioning and public statements from both parties.
OpenAI settlement with NYT by end of 2024?
Yes:15.0%
No:85.0%
Confidence: 8/10
Reasoning Score: 9/10
Sources
- https://news.bloomberglaw.com/ip-law/openai-faces-existential-threat-in-new-york-times-copyright-suit
- https://techcrunch.com/2024/01/08/openai-claims-ny-times-copyright-lawsuit-is-without-merit/
- https://deadline.com/2024/01/openai-new-york-times-lawsuit-1235699448/
- https://static01.nyt.com/newsgraphics/documenttools/82a013b9ba852548/9d4b1790-full.pdf